10.30 – 13.00, Thursday 9th February 2023 (via Microsoft Teams)
Meeting chair: David Slawson (DS), Imperial College London
Microsoft Teams Organiser: Lucy Turner (LT), Forest Research, Alice Holt
Decisions and actions
Actions/matters arising from July 2022 meeting
All were either discharged or were included on the agenda except Actions 1 and 2 concerning summaries of research projects for the website. These summaries are intended to increase the value of the website to external users. DS showed a draft text for the OPAL Tree Health Survey. The format was accepted but a reduction in the word count was advised.
Action (A1) DS to revise and circulate to members the revised template.
Action (A2) Allmembers to submit to LT texts for their projects.
Action (A3) LT to load texts on to the website, including a covering summary list of projects.
Tom Jenkins (Forest Research Wales) (Forest Research Wales) summarised development of the Network’s web pages hosted by Forest Research; he indicated that metrics on usage will be recorded in the future; and invited feedback.
Michael Pocock (CEH) reported that the group now has 65 subscribers and that jiscmail is the main channel for communications within the network.
The next meeting will be a hybrid face-to-face/MS teams meeting on Tuesday 4 July 2023 at Forest Research Alice Holt, Farnham, Surrey.
Action (A4) LT to send an MS Calendar invitation to all members and potential attendees; DS to post a ‘save the date’ message on jiscmail.
Potential venues for future meetings include Yorkshire Arboretum (kindly offered by Ginnette Alexander), RHS Bridgewater Garden near Manchester and Forest Research, Northern Research Station, Roslin near Edinburgh.
Priority actions update
Enhance the tree health surveillance network (DS)
Enhancement of the tree health surveillance network has largely been achieved by various organisations becoming “associate members” of Observatree
Current associate members include National Trust Scotland, Nature Scot, Association of Tree Officers, English Heritage, The Yorkshire Arboretum, Royal Botanic Garden Edinburgh (and its three other gardens Benmore, Dawyck and Logan) and Royal Botanic Garden Kew (and Wakehurst Place).
Active discussions are also in progress with The Tree Council, the Royal Horticultural Society and most recently with PlantNetwork (https://plantnetwork.org) – a charity and membership organisation that provides training and network support to gardens and gardeners throughout Britain and Ireland with 70 member institutions, 1,500 individual members covering over 500 gardens and parks; integral to this collaboration are Botanic Garden Conservation International with their knowledge of a similar system in the USA – American Public Gardens Association – Plant Sentinel Network: Detection, Diagnosis, Protection Education.
Action (A5) Peter Crow and DS to continue discussions with interested organisation
Tree health citizen science ‘learning pathway’(DS)
The “Tree health citizen science learning pathway” was revised following feedback from the previous THCSN meeting
The learning pathway is referenced in “A Plant Biosecurity Strategy for Great Britain 2022”, which was published in January 2023
Matilda Scharsach (Woodland Trust Volunteer Coordinator for Scotland) has kindly recorded a voice -over to accompany the learning pathway
TJ gave a demonstration of the learning pathway and its voice-over; a few suggested amendments were proposed
Action (A6) DS and TJ to finalise revisions and publish the “learning pathway” on the THCSN webpages.
Tour d’table updates from partners/guests
Defra/Plant Health (Jake Morris)
“A Plant Biosecurity Strategy for Great Britain 2023-28”:
Citizen Science is included in Outcome 2: “A society that values healthy plants – Raising awareness of the importance of healthy plants and trees and encouraging the adoption of responsible behaviours across society”
The strategy is supported by a “Public Engagement in Plant Health Accord” which has been signed by 36 supporting organisations
“National Plant Health Week”
Will be held on 8-14 May 2023
Its focus is on encouraging “environmental stewardship”
Will include a Citizen Science-themed day
Action (A7) Jake Morris to update THCSN on developments for the Citizen Science-themed day.
Defra/Natural Capital and Ecosystem Assessment (NCEA) (Richard Ferris)
RF described the Natural Capital and Ecosystem Assessment’s (NCEA) programme of work, including its vision for Natural Environment Citizen Science.
The NCEA includes a vision that Citizen Science-based survey and data are recognised, valued and fully utilised in our collective approach to assess the extent and condition of natural capital and ecosystems
It is delivered via 6 Work Packages: Strategic partnerships, National catalogue, Regional Hubs, Urban Environment, Freshwater Environment and Farmland Environment
Why Natural Environment Citizen Science (NECS) matters and the opportunities for greater use and investment as part of our science & evidence programme
There are well documented challenges as well as opportunities
Support and harness leadership for NECS collaboration
Clarify the NECS activity and experience landscape
Embed best practice NECS principles & ensure confident data use
Understand the costs-benefits / case for investment
Partnerships: Map existing partnerships and their values, identify opportunities to build on these, and ensure that the environmental citizen science sector is strategically aligned to support the recovery of nature:
Current stakeholder mapping
Gap analysis – new, additional stakeholders
Development of new partnership narrative – ‘Our Message’
Establish a new Core National Strategic Partnership Group
Consistency of Citizen Science practice, achieved through setting and use of standards, rigour, and ways of working
Develop and deploy an open set of common resources that the wider community is happy to use, and collaborate on their further development, expansion and standardisation
Best practice guidance made available via an online portal ‘One Stop Shop’
Natural Environment Citizen Science (NECS) Hubs
Investing public resource ‘more locally’ to grow capacity to collaborate, coordinate, and enable NECS
A conduit between national and local flavours of policy, priority, innovation, and representation
Investing in people, skills, time, and participation
Many similarities were noted between tree health citizen science and natural environment citizen science, not just on strategy, partnerships, resources and hubs but also on the value of a learning pathway and the importance of making species data open and accessible e.g. on the NBN Trust and its Atlases.
Action (A8)DS to invite RF to future meetings and to share information on the learning pathway, hubs and data.
MP gave a brief update on the main developments on the Observatree project. Headlines included:
The current network includes 166 volunteers
4,800 reports last year – a record for Observatree: details of the main pests and diseases were presented
A pilot collaboration project is underway with the Tree Council
A very active programme of training and support is provided to volunteers including training resources, a series of webinars, summer training days, mentoring days, monthly newsletter, host of the month and a quiz
A major upgrade to the TreeAlert reporting system is in development and will be launched in March 2023
Action (A9) Lucy Carson-Taylor (APHA) sought slides from Matt’s presentation for use by Prof Nicola Spence (Chief Plant Health Officer) in forthcoming international meetings.
Wales Sentinel Network (Dan Wood, Welsh Government)
rly warning network of 22 parks and gardens in each local authority region across Wales
Includes sites of the National Botanic Garden of Wales, National Trust and local councils
Welsh Government lead on management and public engagement (including information boards, posters, stands at shows, “Be Plant Wise” biosecurity information)
Twice yearly inspections for priority pests and diseases are conducted on each site by staff of the Animal & Plant Health Agency; to date, volunteers are not involved in the surveillance
There is also a Welsh Plant Health Sentinel Network organised by Tom Jenkins, Racheal Lee and Leone Olivieri; four sites are involved and it includes various insect/spore trapping at each site
Treemap – global tree database platform (Richard Maxwell, Tremap)
Thought: there are 6.6 billion smartphone users on the planet. If even just 1% of those can be given the necessary tools, there would be 66 million people equipped to do tree-care citizen science tasksForest Research have a stand at the Royal Welsh Show, 18-21 July 2022 (TJ)
It’s friendly, fun and absolutely simple (learnable in 15 seconds) and a platform that allows people to
digitally label trees
add trees to the Tremap global database
access global tree data
It has functionality to personalise trees, share trees on social media, report on tree health issues to their local council for specific trees (disease, structural damage or risk etc), and to survey, monitor or do tree-care tasks for councils (legion of citizen science Tremappers)
Corporates sponsor tree citizen science programmes and attach logos & URLs to trees
treTube is a gallery of 2-minute video vignettes portraying tree species in-situ, embedded in-app
Global in scope
Developed in the UK
Used around the world
Used in all spheres
The repository for Big Data for Trees
Non-proprietary, but secure (discrete and discreet data)
Open, Collaborative and Connectable-to
A “friendly” shareable, standardized open file format
Static and dynamic sharing of data
The “PDF” of tree datasets.
A web portal
Cloud based (viewable in any browser)
No software to install
Almost no learning curve
No need to keep updating
View, manage and report on tree sub-datasets within the overall Tremap database
Possible next steps
Adopt Individual Tree Data Standard for Tremap internal file structure –facilitates interoperability with other platforms
Develop dynamic data sharing/integration in the UK with NBN, Tree Alert, Woodland Trust ATI –promotes data sharing and openness
Develop relationships with similar entities around the world –builds a unified global dataset, invaluable for larger Big Data tasks
Action (A9) Any members who see synergies between their work and Tremap to contact Richard Maxwell.
Michael Pocock announced that he had just had a paper published on nature-based citizen science benefits well-being and nature connectedness of participants, which adds to the range of activities already proven to enhanced human–nature interactions and nature connectedness.
Samantha Green announced that they would soon be conducting a tree buyers’ survey, which she will post on the jiscmail group
Summary of meeting and close
DS closed the meeting noting that it had perhaps been the most successful meeting to date as it had so successfully connectedpeople and projects from across different fields of tree health (biosecurity), nature and ecosystem services; and that there was consistent messaging around the importance of collaboration and sharing (a) people to conduct surveys and science and (b) data – to record it once and use it for several purposes, including making use of existing platforms, such as the NBN Trust and its Atlases.
We use 3 types of cookie. You can choose which cookies you're happy for us to use.
Strictly necessary cookies
These essential cookies do things like remember your progress through a form.
They always need to be on.
Cookies that measure website use
We use Google Analytics to measure how you use the website so we can improve it based on user needs.
Google Analytics sets cookies that store anonymised information about:
how you got to the site
the pages you visit on forestresearch.gov.uk and how long you spend on each page
what you click on while you're visiting the site
Cookies that help with our communications and marketing
Some forestresearch.gov.uk pages may contain content from other sites, like YouTube or Flickr, which may set their own cookies. These sites are sometimes called ‘third party’ services. This tells us how many people are seeing the content and whether it’s useful.